I have a complicated relationship with Byron Katie's The Work.
If you haven't met it, The Work is a method of inquiry built around four questions. You take a thought that causes you pain and ask: Is it true? Can you absolutely know that it's true? How do you react when you believe that thought? Who would you be without the thought? Then you turn the thought around, find its opposite, and test whether that holds as much truth.
It's elegant. In my view it's also flawed, in ways that matter for women and for anyone whose main way of knowing lives below the mind, and in the body.
The Work leans on a particular model of truth: something examined, verified and checked against evidence. Feeling becomes a hypothesis to test. With a skilled facilitator this can be liberating. With the wrong one, or used by a woman already trained to doubt herself, it can become another tool of self-gaslighting. A woman senses danger in a room, and the inquiry asks her to prove it. She feels the lie in a man's voice, and she is asked whether she can absolutely know. Often she can't. Instinct rarely arrives with a citation.
I've spent much of my working life defending the intelligence of the body. As a physiotherapist and somatic practitioner, I have watched bodies know things months before a scan could confirm them. I have watched women's felt sense get overridden by doctors, partners, institutions and their own trained rationality, at enormous cost. So I come to Katie's work with my guard up.
And still, her practices have been quietly helping me lately, especially in how I relate to men.


