Help me turn writing into a career, not just something I do on the side. Your paid subscription helps me carve out real time for essays — the deeper, slower pieces that I can take my time to write whilst I sip my Oolong in the morning.
Paid subscribers get early (and full) access to new essays, occasional behind-the-scenes notes on what I’m working through & monthly live guest speaker interviews. I hope you enjoy this article.
Big love,
SB x
I am sitting here writing this article this morning, on the other side of the world, still turning over the results of the American midterms. White women, a group that has so often voted for the politics that constrain them, swung toward the other side this time. Yet when you look closer, one line divides them more sharply than any other: education. White women with degrees moved one way, and white women without them largely held to the old allegiance. I can't stop thinking about what that line reveals, and about how long religion and patriarchy have worked to keep women on the far side of it.
Wherever patriarchy has wanted to hold power over women, it has found its way to the same door: the one that leads to learning. Across centuries and continents, women have been told that knowledge would corrupt them, unsex them, distract them from their sacred duties, or simply was not for them. Very often, the authority behind that message was religious.
There is a reason for this. A woman who can read the sacred texts for herself can question the men who interpret them. A woman with her own learning can earn her own living, and a woman with her own living can leave. Education unravels the conditions that make women dependent, and dependence has always been what keeps a patriarchal order standing.
What the data shows
In the United States, education has become one of the sharpest dividing lines in how women relate to traditional gender politics. In the 2026 midterms, white women overall backed Democrats by 6 points, while white women without college degrees still favoured Republicans by 16. Pew has long found that attending college makes a voter much more likely to lean Democratic, with the effect strongest among college-educated women.
The pattern reaches into the home as well. A study of couples by Liat Raz-Yurovich and Barbara Okun found that the woman's tertiary education, more than the man's, best explained how egalitarian a couple's attitudes were and how they divided housework.
The longing for equality, however, is shared across the education line. When sociologists Sarah Thébaud and David Pedulla asked young people what they would choose if workplaces gave real support, 62% of college-educated women and 59.3% of women without a degree preferred an egalitarian relationship. Women everywhere want freedom. Education changes how many of them can reach it.
The scriptural roots
The texts most often used to keep women silent are short, and their influence has been enormous. In the King James Bible, 1 Timothy 2:11–12 reads: "Let the woman learn in silence with all subjection. But I suffer not a woman to teach, nor to usurp authority over the man, but to be in silence." A similar instruction in 1 Corinthians 14 tells women to keep silent in the churches and ask their husbands at home. For centuries these lines were read as divine limits on what a woman could know and who she could teach.
Other traditions carry parallel teachings. In the Mishnah (Sotah 3:4), Rabbi Eliezer warns that teaching a daughter Torah is like teaching her frivolity or lewdness, a view that shaped Jewish women's exclusion from formal religious study for generations. The Hindu law code Manusmriti declares that a woman should never be independent, guarded in turn by father, husband and son, and later commentators used it to bar women from Vedic learning.
Each of these passages has been fiercely debated by scholars within its own tradition. Many Christian scholars read the Timothy passage as addressed to one local church, and point out that Paul names women such as Phoebe and Junia as leaders. Yet the plain-sense readings are the ones that institutions enforced, and those are the readings that shaped women's lives.
Who was allowed to know
Europe's universities grew out of cathedral schools and were built to train clergy, lawyers and physicians, all roles closed to women. From the founding of Bologna in 1088, women were almost entirely shut out for most of the next eight centuries. When Elena Cornaro Piscopia sought a doctorate in theology at Padua in 1678, the Church refused; she was granted one in philosophy instead, becoming the first woman known to earn a doctorate. Oxford did not grant women full degrees until 1920. Cambridge held out until 1948.
For many centuries the convent was the one place a woman could pursue a life of the mind. Hildegard of Bingen wrote theology, medicine, natural history and music from inside its walls in the twelfth century. Her brilliance was permitted because it was enclosed, celibate and placed under the authority of the Church.
The witch trials of the early modern period, in which roughly three in four of those executed were women, are often remembered as a war on female healers and keepers of folk knowledge. Historians now debate how far that story holds; most accused women were poor, old or socially isolated, and midwives appear less often than legend suggests. What the trials did make vivid is how dangerous it could be for a woman to be seen as holding knowledge or power outside sanctioned channels.
The locked door today
Afghanistan shows the pattern at its most extreme. After the Taliban returned to power, girls were barred from secondary school in March 2022 and women from universities that December. Both bans were described as temporary and both remain in force, justified by the Taliban's interpretation of Islamic law. UNESCO estimates that 2.4 million girls have been shut out of secondary education, and calls Afghanistan the only country in the world where girls and women are formally banned from secondary and higher education. It also warns the ban will raise the risk of early marriage.
A quieter version exists in the wealthy West. Within the American Christian patriarchy movement, "stay-at-home daughters" live under their father's authority until marriage and are raised to forgo college and career, training in homemaking instead. Former members describe being taught that college would fill their heads with ungodly thoughts of equality. One woman who grew up in the movement recalls being allowed to skip science for a year because it wasn't considered necessary. Tara Westover's memoir Educated, about leaving a survivalist Mormon family for Cambridge, traces the same arc from a different tradition.
The movement's leaders would say they value education highly, as long as it prepares a daughter for her role as wife and mother. That framing is revealing. The objection is to an education that equips a woman for independence.
Why keeping women unlearned works
The sociologist Deniz Kandiyoti described the patriarchal bargain: the deal a woman makes when she accepts a system that limits women because, inside it, it offers her the most security available. Restricting education is how a system keeps that bargain attractive. Three mechanisms do most of the work.
The first is economic. Without learning, a woman's survival runs through a father, then a husband, then a son, and leaving any of them means destitution. The second is interpretive. When only men can read and teach the sacred texts, only men can say what God wants, and a woman's obedience becomes a matter of faith. The third is imaginative. A woman who has never met other ways of living, other histories, other women who chose differently, has little to compare her life against. Her world feels like the only world.
This is why an educated daughter can feel like the gravest threat a patriarchal family or community faces. She brings home the very tools the system depends on her lacking.
The counter-history
Any honest telling has to hold the other half of the story, because religion has also been one of history's great educators of women. The world's oldest continually operating university, al-Qarawiyyin in Fez, was founded in 859 by Fatima al-Fihri, a Muslim woman who herself studied Islamic law and hadith. A widely cited hadith declares seeking knowledge an obligation on every Muslim, and the Prophet's wife Aisha became one of the most important transmitters of early Islamic teaching.
The Upanishads honour women philosophers such as Gargi and Maitreyi debating the nature of reality. Martin Luther urged towns to open schools for girls so they could read scripture, and Protestant literacy campaigns taught millions of women to read. Quakers educated daughters alongside sons. Catholic teaching orders such as the Ursulines, founded in 1535, built schools for girls across Europe and the Americas.
Today many of the fiercest advocates for girls' education are people of deep faith, Malala Yousafzai among them. The pattern, then, sits with how religion is used. When faith serves to concentrate power in men's hands, women's learning becomes a threat. When faith is lived as a search for truth, it has opened doors for women again and again.
Knowledge as liberation
The library door has been locked many times, and women have opened it every time, often at great cost. Afghan fathers teach their daughters in secret. Former stay-at-home daughters enrol in community college in their twenties. Women in every tradition are reading their own scriptures and finding a different God there.
Education in its fullest sense reaches beyond degrees. It includes literacy in money, in law, in history, and in the body itself: knowing your anatomy, your cycles, your own signals of safety and threat. A woman who knows her own body cannot easily be told that her suffering is sacred. A woman who knows her own mind cannot easily be told that her silence is holy.
The structures that depend on women's ignorance have always known what we are only now saying aloud. An educated woman is free to choose. Every system that fears her choice has given itself away.
An invitation
So I leave you with a question to carry into your body tonight: what were you taught you were not allowed to know? Perhaps it was the inner workings of your own anatomy, or the money in your household, or the right to read a holy text and argue with it. Perhaps it was simply the permission to trust what your body already knew. Wherever the door was locked for you, that is where your education begins.
Then turn outward. Every woman who learns becomes a door for another. Teach your daughters the names of their own body parts and the workings of their own cycles. Put books in the hands of girls who have none. Support the organisations keeping girls' schooling alive in places where it has been outlawed, from the Malala Fund to the secret classrooms of Afghanistan. Ask the women in your life what they always wanted to study, and help them begin.
The structures built on women's silence will last exactly as long as our silence does. So read widely, question boldly, and speak what you come to know. Share this essay with a woman who is ready to open her own locked library, and tell me in the comments: what is the first thing you would study if no one could stop you?



